Beaten in Paris last May, Vincent obtained the conviction of his four attackers, aged between 14 and 17. But despite the insults reported by the victim, the aggravating circumstance linked to homophobia was not retained in the proceedings.
“Catch this dirty faggot, we’re going to deal with him.” It’s, according to Vincent, one of the insults uttered by his attackers before beating him, on May 31, last, in the 10th arrondissement of Paris. Five months after the facts, four teenagers, three aged 14 and the fourth aged 17, appeared before the Beauvais juvenile court, in Picardy (Hauts-de-France). On November 4, they were found guilty of violence in a group resulting in 60 days of total incapacity for work (ITT). Despite the homophobic insults reported by the victim, the aggravating circumstance tied to sexual orientation was not retained in the prosecutions. Contacted by têtu·, Vincent and his lawyer revisit this decision.
It is 5:30 a.m. when Vincent returns home by bike that night. Near the Saint-Vincent-de-Paul church, he encounters four teenagers occupying the bike lane. While he tries to pass, the youths begin to taunt him. A kick to his bike sends him tumbling onto the sidewalk. “They immediately surrounded me when I was on the ground and kicked me in the head. I lost consciousness”, he recounts. When he regains consciousness, his attackers have disappeared. “I woke up in the street, in a pool of blood, my jaw shattered”, he recalls. He manages to get back home before being hospitalized.
“I could have argued on this question”
Fractured jaw, teeth knocked out at the root, arm broken: these injuries earned him 60 days of total incapacity for work (ITT). “I still feel today the physical and psychological consequences of this assault, especially since the attack happened five minutes from my home”, testifies Vincent. A fashion designer in Paris, he cannot afford to interrupt his professional activity for long, due to financial constraints. On the advice of friends who were themselves victims of assaults, he turned to the association Stop Homophobia and began the legal proceedings.
At the hearing, the four teenagers contested the homophobic nature of the assault. “There may have been insults, there may have been that word [“pédé”] , but we didn’t know that he was homosexual”, asserted one of them. A legal argument that, in law, is not sufficient to rule out the aggravating circumstance: Article 132-77 of the Penal Code expressly targets the victim’s sexual orientation, true or presumed, and provides for cases where the violence is accompanied by homophobic remarks. “Pédé remains a homophobic insult”, notes Vincent. Vincent’s lawyer regrets that the homophobic character of the violence was not subjected to a adversarial debate. “The public prosecutor’s office ruled it out from the start. I could have argued on this issue and questioned the defendants about it. That was not made possible”, deplores Me Boué-Diacquenod.
If the four adolescents were found guilty, their penalties remain to be determined. Vincent welcomes this initial decision with relief, but not without bitterness. “I am glad about this decision, but I find the judicial follow-up very light for people who wished me dead”, he reacts. The court will decide on their sanctions in May 2027, following a period of educational probation designed to assess their progress. In the meantime, the four teenagers remain under judicial supervision and with an educational follow-up, including a curfew and bans on contact. Parallel to the judicial procedure, Vincent designed for his clothing brand Pressiat a charity T‑shirt in partnership with Stop Homophobia. A way, for the designer, to extend his commitment against homophobic violence beyond the courts.